Poverty Alleviation

Project

Punjab Economic Opportunities Program (PEOP)

Punjab Economic Opportunities Program (PEOP)

To help alleviate poverty and vulnerability by augmenting the skills-base of low income, poor and vulnerable families through vocational training.

Project

Asset Transfer Program

Asset Transfer Program

To evaluate the effectiveness of asset and cash transfers, hence providing policy recommendations towards designing the best social safety net which can improve incomes of the ultra-poor.

Project

Impact of Social Assistance on Early Childhood Development Among Ultra-Poor Households

Impact of Social Assistance on Early Childhood Development Among Ultra-Poor Households

To study how children’s development in early life is impacted by alternative forms of social protection programs.

Project

Climate Change Initiative [PxD Fighting Poverty Through Climate Action]

Climate Change Initiative [PxD Fighting Poverty Through Climate Action]

PxD’s Advisory with leading agronomists and climate change experts provide key recommendations that enable farmers to better adapt their practices to climate change, as well as help farmers mitigate the potential adverse impacts of climate change to the quality and quantity of their yields.

Punjab Economic Opportunities Program (PEOP)

Low-income countries are increasingly setting up welfare systems and providing economic opportunities for their citizens through cash transfer, employment generation, and skills enhancement programmes. Many of these policies are directed towards those who have been historically excluded from state programmes—the poor, rural inhabitants, and women. The success of such policies relies on these individuals being able to access the benefits provided to them. In practice, we often see “money left on the table” in that studies document how villagers do not obtain subsidised rice, widows fail to take advantage of monthly stipends, and women are unable to obtain vocational training, despite the large gains such programmes may have.

This project aims to help alleviate poverty and vulnerability by augmenting the skills-base of low income, poor and vulnerable families by improving their technical and vocational skills. The main goal is to increase the rate of income growth in poor and vulnerable households in high poverty districts of Southern Punjab – Bahawalpur, Bahawalnagar, Lodhran, and Muzaffargarh.

This project uses experimental variation to estimate the value of one such access constraint—travel that requires a woman to move outside her community. We study a skills development programme in rural Pakistan, which is representative of many underdeveloped regions throughout the world where female mobility—a widely recognised barrier to development —is a challenge for both logistical and cultural reasons.

Date:

2012 – ongoing

Implementing Partners:

Government of Punjab, Punjab Skills Development Fund (PSDF), DFID (FCDO), British Asian Trust, Kaarvan Crafts Foundation

Tags

Social Protection, Poverty, Employment, Economic Mobility, Female Empowerment, Rural Economy, Poverty Alleviation, Technical Skills, Vocational Skills, Welfare Systems, Travel, Female Mobility

Asset Transfer Program

The Asset Transfer Project aims to evaluate the effectiveness of asset and cash transfers, hence providing policy recommendations towards designing the best social safety net which can improve incomes of the ultra-poor.

More than 40 million people live below the national poverty line in Pakistan. Ten million of them reside in the rural southern districts of Punjab. The asset transfer program is being implemented by National Rural Support Program (NRSP) and Farmer Development Organization (FDO) in four districts of Southern Punjab namely; Bahawalpur, Muzaffargarh, Lodhran, and Bahawalnagar. Theoretical research has shown that asset-transfer programmes coupled with complementary training, significantly and permanently raise the economic well-being of ultra-poor households through their engagement in basic entrepreneurship. There is also evidence that UCTs foster entrepreneurial activity. Using randomised control trials, this research is among the first to compare these kinds of asset transfer programmes to UCTs in the local context of Pakistan.

Publications

Policy Brief:

  • The Design of Social Protection Programs for the Ultra-poor: Asset Transfers vs Unconditional Cash Transfers. Dr. Imran Rasul, Dr. Adnan Khan. CERP. PPAF.
Tags

Poverty Alleviation, Social Protection, Impact Evaluation, Experimental Research Design

Impact of Social Assistance on Early Childhood Development among Ultra-Poor Households

The project will in particular use and build on an earlier randomised control trial intervention (part of CERP’s Asset Transfer project) targeted at the poorest households in rural Punjab, Pakistan. In 2014, households were randomly assigned to either receive asset transfers (typically in the form of livestock) or the equivalent unconditional cash transfer. In the subsequent eight years, both forms of social assistance are documented to have substantial impacts on the labour market activities, earnings and investments of treated households.

This project will investigate how each form of social assistance impacted children’s outcomes, for those born prior, during or just after the original intervention. A range of child outcomes will be studied, and measures of cognitive and non-cognitive development for children between the ages of 0-8 years. We will also collect information to identify the mechanisms generating child development outcomes, such as parental beliefs and attitudes. This data will be collected from a sample of ultra-poor households residing in the four Project Districts: Bahawalpur, Bahawalnagar, Muzaffargarh and Lodhran. Three different child development tools (the IDEALA tool for children aged 48 months – 7 years 11 months 30 days, Liz Spelke’s tasks for children aged 36 months – 7 years 11 months 30 days and a brief child development assessment for children aged 6-35 months 30 days) will be used along with a section on mother or primary caregiver’s physical and mental health to measure outcomes at different stages of child development.

The IDELA is an internationally validated tool which has already been used by multiple research teams in Pakistan (https://idela-network.org/about/). All tests are direct assessments except the CREDI which exclusively relies on mother or primary caregiver reports, and thus, primarily focuses on milestones and behaviors that are easy for mothers or primary caregivers to understand, observe, and describe. Interviewers will conduct the surveys with children in the respondents’ homes and the mothers/caregivers will be present at all times during the interview.

Date:

2020-Ongoing

Implementing Partners:

3IE, Yale University

Tags

 Early Childhood Development, Social Assistance, Social Protection, Poverty

Climate Change Initiative [PxD Fighting Poverty Through Climate Action]

Principal Investigators:

Precision Development (PxD) is intensifying their efforts to provide information to smallholder farmers that will allow them to make informed decisions to reduce the risks that climate change presents to their livelihoods and to enjoin their farming and land management activities in the fight against climate change. PxD is focusing on identifying interventions that can improve smallholder livelihoods whilst incorporating climate adaptation and mitigation efforts into their existing services.

PxD’s advisory has been put together with leading agronomists and climate change experts that provide key recommendations that enable farmers to better adapt their practices to climate change, as well as help farmers mitigate the potential adverse impacts of climate change on the quality and quantity of their yields.

PxD’s systems are designed to scale the delivery of customised digital information to individuals and households so that they act on it to improve their well-being and reduce exposure to risks and disasters such as floods and droughts. Their systems are designed to be scaled; as they scale, average costs fall and they improve the cost-effectiveness of their delivery.

Climate-smart advisory, adaptation, and mitigation efforts are already embedded into their programs across all the districts of Punjab in Pakistan, as well as into the day-to-day agricultural activities that PxD farmers carry out. They focus both on climate change adaptation (reducing potential damage) and climate change mitigation (tackling the causes), as the activities and approaches are distinct.

In Punjab, PxD sends out advisory via robocalls and SMS to over 1.3 million farmers. This advisory covers all major cash crop and several types of livestock in Punjab.

Research Questions

  • How climate-vulnerable are the farmers that use PxD’s services?
  • What are the consequences of climate change that are affecting smallholder farmers’ lives?
  • How can we reduce the welfare loss that individual farmers and communities experience, or likely to experience, because of climate change?

Examples of PxD’s work:

  • Some agricultural practices are likely to contribute both to poverty alleviation and climate mitigation if they result in increases in agricultural outputs or income. One such example is promoting optimal and timely application of nitrogen-based fertilizers. PxD’s advisory services in Punjab include recommendations on the optimal application of planting and/or top-down fertilizers. Precise application of nitrogen fertilizers has the potential to cut down farming costs if farmers need to purchase less fertilizer, hence improving smallholders’ agricultural income whilst curbing nitrous oxide emissions.
  • During the summer 2022 flooding in Pakistan, flood warning related advisory sent by PxD enabled some farmers to harvest their crops before the flooding, hence ensuring that they were able to salvage some of their produce.
  • In the recent cotton season, the PxD Advisory recommended the use of yellow sticky cards to farmers to improve their ability to trap and reduce pests. This was also important since lowering the use of synthetic pesticides helps with climate outcomes, improves soil health, and prevents leaching of harmful chemicals and related issues. This led to a sizable reduction in the usage of pesticides and significant cost reductions for farmers.
  • PxD’s recommendations related to livestock include compost management and addition of green fodder to improve feed efficiency.

Date:

2020 – ongoing

Funding Partners:

IFAD

Implementing Partners:

Agriculture Department GOP, IFAD, HarvestPlus, CERP, CFAN, Ayub Agriculture Research Institute, RCDS

Tags

Climate Change, Nutrition, Food Insecurity, Agriculture